I had a batch of exams to grade for my regular Shakespeare gig this weekend. I don’t know how many semesters I have graded for this course, but this exam was undoubtedly the most awesome one ever, due in no small part to one of the essay question options it offered. The students were supposed to discuss the moral and material universes of three of Shakespeare’s great tragic plays (choosing from Lear, Othello, Macbeth, or Antony and Cleopatra) and to say which one they would most like to live in. Only about a third of the exams I read answered this particular question, but they did not disappoint. I was in a hurry and didn’t take time to write down all of the hilarious answers, but here are the very best:
About Macbeth: “A universe based on the words of three crazy witches is not one I would wish to inhabit.” Fair enough.
One student (who clearly hadn’t read A&C) was trying to explain why Othello’s world was more appealing than Macbeth’s or Lear’s, and had to qualify thus: “Though Othello, the play, is concentrated around hate and jealousy, these are human characteristics that are identifiable to me.” Okaaaaaaaaaay. Remind me not to slight you when you’re looking to be my next assistant.
Of course, most people wanted to cozy up with Cleopatra, for obvious reasons: “Every day in Egypt is a party filled with sex, drinking, and music.” Kind of like a certain big ten campus I know of…
Of course, as another student pointed out, even this land of hedonism has its problems: “The multiple wars of the Mediterranean would also be a drawback, however the balanced lifestyle [of A&C] seems much more appealing than Lear and Macbeth.”
Finally, I offer you three recent additions to the english lexicon. I invite you to define them in the comments. Extra bonus points for using all three in a single sentence:
- ominousity
- bestrought
- prescense
[Disclaimer for those new to this blog: Please don't read this as "I think my students are so so dumb." I ascribe any silliness to the in-class exam pressure-cooker and not to the students' intellects; thus I intend posts like these to be taken along the lines of "those cute kids, the things they say!" I have said more about this here. Other earlier installments here and here.]


